Turning Gold into Bullion: Why MS-63 and Lower $20 Pre-1933 Gold Coins Are Being Melted

In today’s market, a growing number of $20 pre‑1933 U.S. gold coins (Saint‑Gaudens and Liberty Head Double Eagles) graded MS‑63 and lower are being melted down. Understanding why this is happening is vital for both investors and collectors who rely on coin inventory management systems like MyCoinWorx to track and protect their assets.

What’s Driving the Melt Trend?

1. Shrinking Numismatic Premiums
   As of March 2025, premiums on pre‑1933 gold coins have dropped to their lowest in 20 years, offering investors a chance to acquire these coins closer to their bullion value rather than at steep collector premiums
2. Bullion Value vs. Collector Worth
   MS‑63 and lower examples offer minimal numismatic enhancement over their melt value. In fact, many circulate-grade coins are currently valued near or just above their gold content — making melting economically sensible
3. Historic Scarcity vs. Practical Use
   While pre‑1933 gold coins are scarce—thanks to massive melt-downs during the 1930s—most surviving coins today are valued more for their metal than for collectible appeal when in lower grades
4. Community Consensus
   On forums, collectors acknowledge that higher spot prices and lower collectible premiums lead to general selling or melting of low-grade coins:

“It is highly probable many sell at melt prices, with gold having reached historic highs.”

Why It Matters for Your Coin Inventory Management Software

If you're tracking your gold coin collection with coin collection systems or coin collection software, understanding this trend empowers you to:

• Flag low-grade coins (MS-63 and below) for possible liquidation
• Track melt value vs. numismatic value efficiently
• Make proactive decisions on whether to retain high-grade pieces or free up funds by selling lesser coins
• Maintain accurate valuation histories in your inventory for insurance, sales, or estate planning

With MyCoinWorx, you can log the grade, certification, and estimated melt value of each coin—then filter for those low-grade $20 gold pieces and decide if melting, selling, or holding is the optimal strategy. If you are a Dealer, you can use MyCoinworX built in metal update system to easily track the current value of metal coin inventory.

Final Thoughts

MS-63 and lower $20 pre-1933 gold coins are increasingly treated as gold bullion rather than collectibles, especially in a market with compressed premiums. Leveraging a coin inventory management system like MyCoinWorx helps collectors make smart, data-driven choices—whether that means melting, holding, or showcasing high-grade examples. With the increased activity in melting, perhaps this gives collectors a chance at coins that will increase in value due to reduction in survivability?

‍